Here's the thing - -
The State of Utah has no attorney general right now. The last two, Bishop Swallow and Shark Murtleff, are both being investigated by the feds for fraud and corruption. The latter made it his mission to exploit polygamists for political gain. The former says he comes from polygamy and has nothing but warm feelings for its practitioners. Either way, technically, their future successor is duty-bound to defend Utah's laws and appeal today's (12/13/13) ruling from the District Court striking down the cohabitation prong of Utah's idiotic bigamy statute.
But here's the thing - judge Waddoups' decision is so well reasoned and so constitutionally sound, that any appeal will be an uphill battle. Since virtually none of the facts is in dispute, the only controversy is whether or not the language and execution of the bigamy statute are legally sound.
Waddoups voids the "cohabitation" prong as operationally unsound because by the nature of its enforcement it singles out a religious minority for disfavorable treatment (AND because it ignores the freedoms reiterated by the 2003 Lawrence decision).
More importantly, however, Waddoups takes his scalpel to the heart of Utah's polygamy foes by attacking the centerpiece of their arguments - compelling government interest. Utah's bigamy statute defenders argue that the higher courts must not apply any heightened or strict scrutiny to the bigamy statute because it was framed under a clearly "rational" basis - namely the compelling state interest of protecting the institution of monogamous matrimony in Utah. Aside from the fact that that argument is silly (does the fact that gay people walk Utah's streets injure the Judeo-Christian institution of holy matrimony?), Waddoups reminds us that since more than ONE of the Browns' constitutional liberties have been hurt, the review standard is driven by the "hybrid rights" doctrine developed in Employment Division v. Smith. Simply put, when both your 14th Amendment (due process) and 1st Amendment (free exercise) rights have been harmed, the level of scrutiny required of the appellate courts is now HEIGHTENED scrutiny. Turley and Waddoups articulated no fewer than six constitutional harms inflicted upon the Browns by the statute and its enforcers. This means that the state can no longer cower behind the pathetic rational-basis argument about protecting traditional marriage at the expense of the Browns' freedoms.
Thus the court(s) has a duty to take a good hard look at the spirit and effect of the statute and to see if it survives constitutional analysis. Kody Brown has four ladies. He sleeps with all of them. Many Utahns can be said to have done the same thing, just not calling their partners "wives". Prosecuting Brown for using the wrong word violates his free speech liberties - not to mention his freedom of association and right to equal protection under the law.
Here's the thing - - I invite Utah's next AG to take a swing at the decision in the 10th Circuit. Waddoups has covered every base in his 91 pages. Any appeal has to draw on a strong legal argument refuting Waddoups and demonstrating the critical merits of criminalizing religious polygamists. I submit that it cannot be done. No self-respecting 10th Circuit jurist would dare disagree with one paragraph of Waddoups' ruling.
Think of it this way - - millions of Americans are deeply resentful of gay marriage. Their religious sensitivities are mortified at its proliferation. However, when you get right down to it, the anti-gay-marriage arguments are all groundless and emotional. My favorite one is the one asserting that children do best when raised in a two (-gender) -parent home. That makes a lot of sense. The problem is that you cannot compel that. If two lesbians are already raising a kid, it is unlikely that that kid's upbringing will deteriorate simply because the two mothers get a legal marriage certificate. The argument falls apart.
Same thing with plural marriage. Utah has had tens of thousands of polygs for 150 years. Traditional monogamous matrimony cannot be demonstrated to have suffered as a result. There is no rational way to argue that it has. Perhaps monogamous marriage has suffered FAR MORE as a result of people getting divorced. Yet the government makes no attempt to outlaw divorce.
So, I say to Gary Herbert and his prospective AG nominee, "Have at it! Send Jerrold Jensen or Laura DuPaix to Denver to argue that polygamists hurt Utah by existing, and that they all need to go to prison. See how far you get with that!" The principal reason (and Waddoups observed this) why these arguments fall flat is because they are tendered in bad faith. These AG lackeys have NO DESIRE to prosecute polygamists, they just want to wag the moralistic finger of LDS piousness to menace an unpopular minority. Waddoups saw through it.
All the more delicious is the fact that Waddoups is a home-grown BYU graduate who finally saw through the hypocrisy and bigotry, and dared to buck the trend. I almost wonder if he isn't going to get pulled in by his Stake President and threatened with disfellowshipment for making the LDS Church look (even more) like a fool.
See you in Denver, Laura.
--------------------------------
Labels
10th Circuit
13th Amendment
14th Amendment
1953 Short Creek Raid
1st Amendment
6th Circuit
Abortion
Abraham
Addam Swapp
Admiralty
adultery
Affordable Care
AG - Craig Jones
AG - Mark Shurtleff
Ahmedinejad
Al Sharpton
Alan Dershowitz
Albert Nock
Alex Jones
Alina Darger
Allen Keate
Allen Steed
Amnesty
Anders Breivik
Andrew Napolitano
Angela Corey
Anteater
Anthony Weiner
Anti-bigamy
Apocalypse
Arm of flesh
Arnold Schwarzenegger
Ashton Kutcher
Assad
atheism
B.C. Supreme Court
bailout
bailouts
Barack Hussein Soetoro Obama
Barack Obama
Barbie
BarefootsWorld.net
Belief vs. Practice
Ben Bernanke
Benghazi
Bernie Machen
Bestiality
Betty Jessop
Big Love
bigamy
Bill CLinton
Bill Medvecky
Blacks and the Priesthood
blood
Blood Atonement
Bolshevik Revolution
Book burning
Bountiful
Boyd K. Packer
Branch Davidians
Breitbart
Brigham Young
Brown v. Herbert
Bruce R. McConkie
Bruce Wisan
Canada
Canada Reference
Carolyn Jessop
Casey Anthony
Caylee Anthony
Chapter 13 bankruptcy
Charles Darwin
Charlie Hebdo
Charlie Sheen
Chick-Fil-A
Chief Justice Robert Bauman
Child-bigamy
Chris Serino
Christine Durham
Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Saints
Church Police
Civil War
Clark Waddoups
CNN
cohabitation
collaboration
Colonia Lebaron
Colorado City
Communism
Conrad Murray
Conservative
Constitution
Country Music
CPS
Craig Barlow
Craig Jones
Creston
Crimea
crooked judge
cultural genocide
Czar Nicholas
D+C 101
Dallin H. Oaks
Dan Cathy
Darwin
Darwin's Black Box
Darwin's Doubt
Darwinian
Darwinism
Darwinists
David Boies
David Koresh
David Leavitt
Davis v. Beason
DCFS
Debra Weyermann
decertification
Decriminalization
Democrat
Denise Lindberg
Depends
Deuteronomy 28
Diaper
Disodium Guanylate
Disodium Inosinate
DNA
Doctrine & Covenants
DOMA
Don't Ask Don't Tell
Donald Trump
Dr. Drew Pinsky
Dr. Seuss
Dream Mine
Dred Scott
Drew Pinsky
Drones
Edom
Edomites
Egypt
El Baradei
Elaine Tyler
Eldorado
Elijah Abel
Elissa Wall
Enabling Act
Entitlement
Ephraim
eradication
Eric Holder
Ernst Zundel
escape
European Union
Eurpoean Bailout
Eustace Mullins
Evolution
Ex Parte
extradition
Ezra Taft Benson
FBI
Federal Reserve
Felony
FEMA camp
Feminazi
First Amendment
Flagellum
flatulence
FLDS
Flora Jessop
Florida
Flying Circus
Food waste
fornication
Fourteenth Amendment
Free-Agency
Fundamentalist Mormon
Fundamentalist Mormons
Gadianton Robbers
Gary Herbert
Gathering
Gay
Gay Marriage
General Conference
genocide
George Clooney
George W. Bush
George Washington
George Zimmerman
Germany
Gerunds
Glue-sniffing
Gordon B. Hinckley
Grant Morrison
Greece
Greg Abbott
GritsForBreakfast
Gun-Control
guts
H1N1
Handbook of Instructions
Harry Reid
Harvey Hilderbran
hatred
HB-99
HBO
Health Care Reform
Heber C. Kimball
Hildale
Hillary Clinton
Hippies
Hitler
Hoax
Holding Out Help
Holding Out Hostages
Holly Madison
Holocaust
Homeland Security
Homeschooling
homosexuality
Hoole
Hosni Mubarak
House of Cards
Hubris
Hugh Hefner
Human Nature
Hypocrisy
hypocrite
Idumea
illegal aliens
Illegal Ceremony
IMF
Immigration
IN TIME
incest
Intelligent Design
International Monetary Fund
Iowa Supreme Court
Iran
Irony
Irrevocable Clause
Isaac Jeffs
Jacob Zuma
Jaimee Grubb
James Dobson
James Rosen
Jamie Dimon
Jan Brewer
Jane Blackmore
Janet Yellen
Jeff Ashton
Jeff Buhman
Jeffs
Jerrold Jensen
Jerry Sandusky
Jesse Barlow
Jesus Christ
Jew
Jim Jones
Jimmy Oler
Joe Darger
Joe Paterno
John Boehner
John Daniel Kingston
John F. Kennedy
John H. Koyle
John Hyrcanus
John Kerry
John Singer
John Swallow
John Taylor
Jon Krakauer
Jonathan Turley
Jonestown Massacre
Joni Holm
Jose Baez
Joseph Compton
Joseph Henrich
Joseph Smith
Joy Behar
JP Morgan Chase
Jubilee
Judea
Judge Barbara Walther
Judge Bauman
Judge Clark Waddoups
Judge Dee Benson
Judge Donald Eyre
Judge James Brady
Judge Robert Shelby
Judge Terry Christiansen
Judge Waddoups
Julian Assange
June 26th
Jury
Justice Christine Durham
Justice Nehring
Justice Robert Bauman
Justin Timberlake
K Dee Ignatin
Kathy Jo Nicholson
KD Ignatin
keep sweet
Keith Dutson
Ken Driggs
Kendra
Keystone Kops
kidnapping
Kiev
Kimberly Conrad
Kingston
Kirk Torgensen
knife
Kody Brown
Lab rats
Lance Armstrong
Larry Beall
Las Vegas
Laura DuPaix
Laurie Allen
Lavar Christensen
Lawrence decision
Lawrence v. Texas
LDS
LDS Church
Lehi Police
Liberal
Liberals
library
Lifeboat
Lindberg
Lost Boys
Love Times Three
Lukumi
Lyle Jeffs
Main Street Plaza
Mancy Nereska
Marilyn Monroe
Mark E. Petersen
Mark Shurtleff
marriage license
Marxist
Mary Batchelor
Merrianne Jessop
Merril Jessop
Michael Behe
Michael Dorn
Michael Jackson
Michael Zimmerman
middle-class
Migraine Relief
Mike de Jong
Mike Noel
military
miscegenation
missionaries
Mitt Romney
Modern Pharisee
Monkeys
monogamy
Monosodium Glutamate
Monty Python
Mormon
Mormon Church
Mormon Matters
MSG
Mubarak
murder
Muslim polygamy
Musser
Nancy Pelosi
Naomi Jeffs
Natalie Malonis
National Debt
National Enquirer
Natra-Bio
natural selection
Nazi
Next Generation
Ninth Circuit
Nobel Peace Prize
Norway
NSA
Obacle
Obama
Obamacare
Obaminacare
obesity
Occupy Wall Street
Oligarchy
Open Marriage
Orrin Hatch
Osama Bin Laden
Pakistan
Palestine
Papandreou
Paris France
Parker Douglas
patriarchy
Paul Murphy
Paul Ryan
pharaoh
Planets
Planned Parenthood
Playboy mansion
plural marriage
polyamory
polygamist
polygamous
polygamous grouping
polygamous sect
polygamy
polygamy reference
Polygamy Task Force
Predictor
Presbyterian
Presidential Election
promotional video
Promulgate
Prophecy
Proposition 8
Prostitute
Protection of Marriage
Punk'd
Quantitative Easing
race card
Rand Paul
rape
Raymond Jessop
Reassignment
Recession
Reconciliation
Relief Mine
Religion
religious test
Rep. John Lewis
Rep. Mike Noel
Resurrection
Revelation 18:3
Reynolds decision
Richard Dawkins
Richard Nixon
Rick Santorum
Rights
riots
Robert Mueller
Rocky Ridge
Rodney Holm
Rodney King
Roe v. Wade
Ron Paul
Rothschild
Rozita Swinton
Ruby Ridge
Rulon Allred
Russia
Safety Net
Salmonella
Samaria
San Angelo
Sargon
Sarin
Saudi Arabia
Schleicher County
Sean Reyes
Seattle
Second Amendment
Senator Kevin Van Tassell
Shalmaneser
Shannon Price
Shoshana Grossbard
Shutdown
Siamese
Signature in the Cell
Silsby
Silvio Berlusconi
Sir Evelyn de Rothschild
Sister Wives
skin color
Slippery Slope
Socialism
Sonny Hostin
Soviet Union
Spencer W. Kimball
Star Trek
Stars
Stephanie Colgrove
Stephen C. Meyer
Steven Conn
stimulus
Stromberg-Stein
Survival
Suspect Class
Swine Flu
Syria
Tapestry
Ted Stewart
Teen pregnancy
Temple
Teresa Jeffs
termites
Texas
Texas CPS
Texas FLDS
Texas Rangers
The Fall of Reynolds
Theodore Olson
Thirteenth Amendment
Thomas S. Monson
Thurgood Marshall
Tiger Woods
Timothy Geithner
Timothy McVeigh
Titanic
Tito Valdez
TLC
Todd Shackelford
Tom Green
Tonia Tewell
Trace Gallagher
tracting
Trayvon Martin
trickle-down economics
Trip-Wire
Trust
TSA
twins
TxBluesman
Tyranny
U.S. Bankruptcy. Franklin D. Roosevelt
U.S. Supreme Court
UEP
UEP Trust
Ukraine
Uncommon Dissent
Uniform Commercial Code
Universe
University of Oslo
usury
Utah
Utah A.G.
Utah Amendment 3
Utah Attorney General's Safety Net
Utah bigamy statute
Utah Legislature
Utah Supreme Court
Vera Black
Vermont
Vladimir Putin
Waco
Wally Bugden
Wally Oppal
Warburg
Warren Jeffs
weapon words
Wendell Nielsen
Whistleblowers
Wilford Woodruff
William Dembski
William E. Jessop
Willie Jessop
Winston Blackmore
Wisan
Woodrow Wilson
Worf
WTC 7
Xenarthra
Yams
YFZ
YFZ Raid
YFZ Ranch
Zombies